malaysia needs our help

by Sophie Campbell
(SA)

No Swimming!

No Swimming!

Hi, my name is Sophie Campbell, and I'm a year seven from Craigmore South Primary School.

Recently I have been doing a project on the water pollution in Malaysia.

It is terrible, there is a scarce amount of fresh water for tribal groups in Malaysia and they depend on that river supply to live. They use it for crops, bathing, drinking, and for the animals who live in the water.

Due to the construction around a lot of Malaysia's rivers, the surrounding soil has no tree roots to hold on to, so when it rains it wears down by erosion and ends up in the river, which causes it to become all dirty and disgusting. The fish and things in the water die and the drinking water is disgusting, and you wouldn't want to bathe in it. The water is also getting polluted by industries dumping waste in Malaysia's waters and it's washing into the rivers.

I don't think this should go on; I'm sure that you wouldn't want this to happen to your water supply.

Sophie Campbell.

Barry's Response - Sophie, you have a real concern here.

I hope you and this country can do something about this.

Search this site for more information now.

Atmospheric ripples, alchemy, rants and ethics

Sophie's description of Malaysia's polluted rivers, where vital water suffers from erosion and industrial neglect, demands our attention. This isn't just water pollution; it's a profound failure of stewardship. In the face of corporate and political bodies that allow it, we must insist on the foundational principle: integrity compels us to protect the vulnerable, whether it's a tribal water source or scientific data.

Mud and filth Sophie describes choking rivers (a local problem caused by massive PM10 and sediment loads) hint at a much bigger issue. As these pollutants evaporate (releasing volatile organic compounds - VOCs) or aerosolize from water surface tension, they join the vast atmospheric cocktail that controls weather and affects our climate. The human contribution pales in comparison to the planet's original, massive atmospheric alchemists: volcanoes, cosmic rays, and solar radiation.

It's time to stop treating the atmosphere like a predictable bathtub that overflows only when we do something. Instead, we should see it as a cosmic engine powered by immense, natural forces. Think about the Sun's output and Earth's orbital mechanics (the Milankovitch Cycles) that stretch and squish our planet's position relative to the Sun over tens of thousands of years. These cause environmental effects in the form of ice ages, massive, cyclic shifts that dwarf the slight temperature changes often attributed to humans.

Cloud cover formation is profoundly affected by solar magnetic activity, which, as the planet's primary thermal regulator, recasts the whole climate debate. In major climate models, these natural factors get minimal weight, often discounted to zero. An intentional omission like this creates a narrative that shames local polluters but ignores the celestial rhythm that really controls global warming. Let's acknowledge that the sun is the star of this show, and demand models that account for its variations accurately, so citizens can think freely without being coerced.

🧪 The Atmospheric Alchemist's Guild

In the future, environmental action will be a fascinating, contentious adventure. The Rogue River Detective lets you track a pollutant from a Malaysian factory's drain, watch it volatilize from the water into the air, and then compare its atmospheric impact with the effect of a simulated solar flare.

Guessing isn't our thing. We quantify

By treating the reader like a fellow investigator, this approach revolutionizes engagement. The question shifts from "Are humans bad?" (yes, quite often) to "What are the true weights of all the factors?" This integrates the legitimate concerns of environmental skeptics who demand empirical, comprehensive data before accepting radical policy. A good solution doesn't reside in alarmism, but in a sober, detailed analysis of all inputs, whether they come from a corroded pipe in Malaysia or the sun's core.

Bit of a tangent here, but the environment is complex. Don't let the alarmists take over. What would you insist the world measure more accurately if you were the Ecological Alchemist? Leave a comment!

Comments for malaysia needs our help

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Rating
starstarstarstarstar

by: Barry

It's clear that Sophie's powerful message and the article have sparked a vigorous debate about local tragedy, global truth, and ethical responsibility.

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
reply
by: Jenis

Yeah it is true that you have said. I know that in Malaysia, the tribal groups are not getting sufficient pure water for their needs. It's terrible to hear that they have been using the polluted river water for their daily needs including to drink and cooking food. Malaysian government has exceeded the time limit to act up on this situation.

From Barry - Jenis, you've got the ethical urgency down. There's a moral gravity well in the idea that anyone, especially those who rely on a single water source, suffers from such neglect. You pierced through the bureaucratic fog with your point about the government exceeding the deadline.

Meteorologically, this prolonged pollution creates an unfortunate feedback loop. As the water gets dirty with organic waste, dissolved oxygen is depleted, causing the fish to die. However, the water that evaporates from that polluted river is still pure H2O. In the main article, Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) evaporation is the real aerial villain. The VOCs waft up into the humid Malaysian air, where they cook.

Photochemistry converts them into ground-level ozone and secondary organic aerosols (SOAs). While the water looks bad, the air above it brews an invisible, smoggy cocktail, effectively punishing the tribal groups twice. We should demand action not just for the fish, but for the people too.

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Malaysia
by: Anonymous

Thank you for your concern Sophie. I would like to make some updates on Malaysia. There are no tribal groups in Malaysia. We are made up of three main races which are the Malays, Chinese and Indians. There are still some 'orang asli' (or natives) staying in very remote areas in Malaysia, which is very far away from development, thus not exposed to pollution.

We have an abundant supply of fresh water, and the authorities have taken stern actions on those who pollute. Factories clean up the water for aeration, thus putting back clean water into the rivers. I would not deny that there are still people who are still irresponsible and pollute the environment, but don't worry; the environment here is generally clean.

Make a trip to Malaysia if you are able to. We have lots of tourists here. Beautiful beaches, clean rivers, waterfalls, and of course, wonderful foods.

From Barry - Thanks for the update and inviting us to see Malaysia's beautiful reality. You brought up a good point about how complex the population is. Malaysia's diverse social fabric includes three major racial groups, as well as Orang Asli (native peoples).

That the authorities take stern action and factories clean the water for aeration (replacing oxygen) is exactly what we hope for from responsible governance! The aeration process is a brilliant, direct application of environmental engineering.

Let's stir up the atmosphere a bit. You're right, development is far from remote Orang Asli areas. Pollution doesn't respect political or geographical boundaries in developed, industrial areas where VOCs are generated. Tropospheric winds - part of the global atmospheric circulation we talked about - regularly transport this industrial air baggage across state lines and sometimes even across the Malacca Strait!

The infamous Haze event (often caused by biomass burning, which produces enormous amounts of PM2.5) shows how unpredictable meteorological conditions can be. Haze doesn't discriminate between developed and remote areas. All factories should not only clean their wastewater, but (ideally) capture every last one of those sneaky VOCs before they fly to an untouched spot!


Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Something should be done
by: Anonymous

This is really very scary and the authorities should do aomething about it.

From Barry - You've echoed Sophie's concern: Take action. Not just the visible sludge, but the invisible inertia of inaction is the scariest part.

The Earth's climate system works on centuries, while politicians and corporations work on quarters. We have to bridge that time gap.

To predict air flow in cities, consultants use highly detailed, sub-grid scale models. Authorities ignore small-scale meteorology and chemistry when it comes to local pollution. Heavy metals and persistent organic pollutants (POPs) settle in river mud, where they stay for decades.

Inaction locks in a long-term problem that will take heroic, expensive efforts to fix. Science demands foresight; ethics demand action now.

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Good Job
by: Terri

Good job Sophie! We need more awareness when it comes to unhealthy water in countries that need help.

From Barry - "Good Job Sophie!" sums it up perfectly. The reason she did a good job was because she focused on the tangible tragedy and the vulnerable people.

You're right: awareness is the first step. We need to upgrade that awareness from sympathy to scientific literacy. We should demand every country publish their local air quality index (AQI) along with their water quality index (WQI) instead of just saying "water is bad."

It's important to see the SOAs (derived pollution) that float above polluted water, the particulate matter that drifts from erosion, and the SO2 and NOx emissions that cause acid rain. Public needs to understand that air and water are interconnected-and both are in trouble right now!

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
What can be done?
by: Christine

If there are no laws or rules regarding the dumping of waste in the Malaysian waters, then maybe people could get together and work to convince the government that dumping laws should be implemented. And it would be great if someone could organize volunteers to plant some deep-root trees that would help the soil stick better to prevent erosion. I think there's a lot of opportunity for environmental groups to get involved!

It'd be great to see a follow-up on things that organizations are doing to help Malaysia with their water pollution issues.

From Barry - Christine, you've changed the conversation from worry to opportunity. Organizing volunteers for deep-root tree planting and lobbying the government for dumping laws are brilliant, ethical applications of conservative principles.

Deep-root tree planting is a meteorological and hydrological powerhouse! Trees do a lot of unsung environmental good:
- Their roots bind the soil, so less sediment is washed into rivers (PM10). There's less sediment in the river, so water flows better.
- Trees release pure water vapor into the atmosphere, which can temper extreme heat islands and increase local humidity.
- Their leaves act as natural PM2.5 and PM10 scrubbers, capturing airborne dust and industrial aerosols that might otherwise get back into the water.

You've got a great idea for a follow-up. Maybe we should make a "Stewardship Scorecard" that tracks environmental groups not just by their fundraising, but by their measurable impact on the air and water!

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Great Article
by: Anita

I completely agree - all dirty and disgusting water. The fish and other living beings in the water die, and the drinking water gets disgusting.

From Barry - You've captured the absolute tragedy: the direct, immediate death of aquatic life. Biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) happens when water is disgusting with organic waste. Fish and other organisms starve (asphyxiate).

Let's add some science to this depressing picture. Methane (CH4) and hydrogen sulfide (H2S) are released by dying fish and decomposing organic matter. Over a 20-year period, methane is many times more powerful than CO2 as a greenhouse gas. Polluted rivers aren't just a local disaster; they're a major atmospheric irritant, silently pumping powerful warming-agents into the air above the tropics.

We need not just cleanup, but full restoration, so the natural river chemistry can re-establish balance, stop the BOD process, and prevent these pollutants from getting into the atmosphere. Mind the air and water, from the microscopic bacteria to the global methane budget.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Water Pollution.



Do you have concerns about air pollution in your area??

Perhaps modelling air pollution will provide the answers to your question.

That is what I do on a full-time basis.  Find out if it is necessary for your project.



Have your Say...

on the StuffintheAir         facebook page


Other topics listed in these guides:

The Stuff-in-the-Air Site Map

And, 

See the newsletter chronicle. 


Thank you to my research and writing assistants, ChatGPT and WordTune, as well as Wombo and others for the images.

OpenAI's large-scale language generation model (and others provided by Google and Meta), helped generate this text.  As soon as draft language is generated, the author reviews, edits, and revises it to their own liking and is responsible for the content.